Best Vehicle Sound Deadener / Fatmat vs Kilmat vs Noico vs Dynamat
So here’s all the information you need to know about Fatmat, Noico, Kilmat, and Dynamat to help you make the right choice.
- Can adhere to any car surface
- Features a butyl-based material and has asphalt undercoating
- At 80 mils thick, it’s denser than Dynamat and several other soundproofing mats. This makes it highly efficient at providing sound insulation.
- Installation is easy thanks to the material coming with an installation indicator which will alert you if the mat isn’t installed properly
- Even though it’s bulky at 80 mils, Noico mats are surprisingly lightweight at about 0.7lbs for every square foot.
- Available in multiple sheets, precisely nine sheets which makes installing it in various parts of your vehicle possible.
If you don’t want the Noico material with the foil top layer because you think its look will ruin aesthetics, Noico offers you the alternative of an all-black version of its material. This alternative is called merely Noico Black Car Sound Deadening.
Noico mats can be installed anywhere you please, and that includes rooms in your home where you believe silence is golden. But the material does its best work in an automobile by eliminating general noise and more.
For a better picture of if Noico sound deadeners are for you, here are some primary pros and cons of the product.
Noico Sound Deadening Material Pros and Cons
- Great price that ensures affordability
- User-friendly to install
- Thick and lightweight
- Works on any automotive surface
- Protection gloves are a must when installing
- The rubber smell can be off-putting in the closed space of a car
- Roller for installation is not included.
- The foil can significantly block the rubber smell, but the foil is relatively thin
Overall, Noico sound deadening mats are suitable for soundproofing vehicle roofs, doors, trunks, and other parts. While the rubbery smell is something to consider, its affordable price and soundproofing performance make it a worth it buy.
Asides from its ability to deaden road noise and internal vibrations, other features of Kilmat that make it a top choice include:
- The product features a universal material that ensures the material can be installed anywhere outdoors or indoors as a sound insulator. You can install it inside a vehicle or outside on the hood or wheel well.
- Kilmat doesn’t stink of rubber or have any other offensive odor. Even the adhesive used to stick it on is odorless.
- The adhesive on the Kilmat material is designed to stick fast and last long. The adhesive is already on the mat, so this makes installation quick and easy.
- Sound insulation and heat insulation rolled into one product to give you a less noisy and cozier ride.
- Each sheet of Kilmat sound deadener mat is of a manageable size that makes handling and installing it more comfortable. There are a total of 34 sheets in the pack.
Kilmat Sound Deadening Material Pros and Cons
Still not sure if Kilmat is the right product for you? These pros and cons will help you make up your mind.
- Affordable price without compromising on quality
- No bad odor
- Suitable for internal and external installation
- Thick and lightweight
- Powerful, long-lasting adhesive
- Small size sheets that are easy to work with
- The sheets are relatively stiff which can slow down the installation process.
- Doesn’t come with a roller
While the Kilmat 80 mil is not as popular as Noico’s, it’s definitely a great product. And since you will be getting all the benefits of a Noico product at a lesser price and minus the odor, the Kilmat sound deadener makes for a better alternative.
Dynamat is possibly the most popular brand of sound deadener on this list. Custom builders have been using the product for years and have been recommending it to their clients for a quieter and more comfortable ride. But is it all talk from a big brand or has Dynamat earned its status?
Dynamat’s products are the go-to solution for many vehicle owners looking to keep noises and vibration in their vehicle to the barest minimum. The product comes highly recommended for its sound insulation efficiency which exceeds that of most other products on the market.
Dynamat’s sound deadeners are highly versatile and are suitable for installation both within and outside a vehicle. In fact, they can even be installed in homes and offices to enhance sound insulation.
When installed in the interior of a vehicle, this 50 mils thick material will significantly cut down vibrations and road noise. It is available in made to measure packs which means installation can be easily accomplished anywhere and on any surface with ease.
But installing the Dynamat does require a bit of patience and expertise. That said, if properly installed, you can look forward to long-lasting and top quality sound insulation.
Most of the complications during installation come from the material being quite dense, which makes it difficult to fold into certain spaces.
As earlier stated, while Dynamat is great for reducing noise and vibrations in vehicles, it is also suitable for installation in other places where you’d like to minimize noise.
For instance, you are more than welcome to install Dynamat to soundproof your study or nursery. You can even use it to soundproof your home theater.
Where and how you use the product is entirely up to you and your noise reduction goals. But because Dynamat isn’t cheap, using it to soundproof a large space can prove to be quite pricey.
So how much exactly does Dynamat cost and is it worth it?
This is a very good question especially if you are considering Dynamat as an alternative to the less pricey options of Noico and Kilmat.
Before we talk about the actual price of Dynamat, it’s important to note that top quality usually costs top dollar. By that reasoning, Dynamat offers a great quality product at a good value.
Where Kilmat will cost you $1.65 per square foot, Dynamat will cost you about $5 per square foot. That’s a big price difference that comes along with a promise of guaranteed performance.
Dynamat Sound Deadening Material Pros and Cons
To determine if Dynamat truly delivers good value for cash, let’s take a look at some of its biggest pros and cons.
- Top-quality performance car soundproofing
- Odorless soundproofing material
- Unlike asphalt based products, Dynamat is heat-resistant. It can also serve as an effective heat insulator
- The product’s aluminum coating ensures quality performance and durability
- Not limited to one size as you can order for custom packs of sizes that best fit the specific areas you’d like to soundproof
- Can get a sample to test its effectiveness before buying a package.
- The material is made with sophisticated ingredients that ensure a high-performance sound control
- Doesn’t require heating before installing
- The material is flexible and stretchy thus will not tear easily after being installed
- The installation process requires patience and quite a bit effort
- It is more expensive than other alternatives that are just as effective
- A separate roller has to be purchased for installation.
- You’ll need to get Dyna tapes separately to seal the seams of adjacent mats
If you intend on soundproofing a large vehicle or room with Dynamat, it’s going to cost you far more than using Noico or Kilmat.
Dynamat’s popularity is earned from its status as a top quality product that delivers impressive results. The price is high, and you might like that, but the amount of effort it takes to install this product may be considered by some to be a turnoff.
Either way, Dynamat delivers reliable soundproofing, which is what is most important. Just be prepared to pay extra for its brand name and market proven quality.
The most important things you need to know about FatMat sound deadener upfront is that it’s thicker than Dynamat but less expensive, and as thick as Kilmat but more costly. Although, it is cheaper than Noico.
With its 80 mils thickness and lower price, FatMat makes for a worthy alternative to Dynamat. It’s also versatile enough to handle a variety of demanding jobs.
What truly differentiates FatMat from Noico, Kilmat and Dynamat are what it’s made of. Unlike the other three, FatMat uses an asphalt-based material to block out annoying and irritating sounds. This isn’t necessarily a good thing as asphalt as certain features that make it less effective than a butyl-based sound deadener.
Nonetheless, Fatmat makes for a fairly priced soundproofing alternative and its 80 mils thick material comes in 18-inch wide rolls. The material can be easily cut into suitable sizes to fit your specific installation needs.
It can be installed on dashboards, in trunks, on door panels, floors, and any other area of a vehicle where you’d like to minimize noise.
Regarding effectiveness, FatMat works well for sound isolation and boosting sound quality within the room it is installed. But the fact that the material is asphalt-based comes with some downsides. Chief of which is asphalt doesn’t do well in high temperatures.
Unlike Dynamat which is heat resistant, FatMat’s asphalt-based material conducts heat and can turn the interior of a vehicle blistering during hot weather. This makes FatMat more suitable for people who live in colder regions.
Also, even though it’s thicker than Dynamat, its noise cancelation capabilities are not as impressive. On the upside, the product is easier to install when compared to Dynamat.
Unlike Dynamat, FatMat is self-adhesive which makes applying and installing it more straightforward. But because if its asphalt base, the mat can be hard to install unless the heating temperature is just right.
One also needs to make sure that the material doesn’t adhere to any other surface but the one that it is to be applied to, including itself. This is because once FatMat sticks, getting it to unstick is almost impossible.
FatMat Sound Deadening Material Pros and Cons
To help you decide if FatMat is the right choice for you, here are some of its major pros and cons.
- The material can be ordered to specifications. This way, you don’t have to order for any more than you need.
- Easy peel off release paper
- Cutting it is easy
- Comes with an impressive money back guarantee
- Very powerful adhesive
- Can stick powerfully to sheet metal and a variety of other hard surfaces
- Effectively absorbs vibrations and noises
- Affordable price. Far cheaper than Dynamat
- Keeps the sounds you want in and the noises that you don’t want out
- A strong odor that can linger for some time after installation
- Once installed, removing the material can be very difficult. After removing the material, a difficult to remove residue may remain
- Because it’s asphalt base, it can lead to a significant rise of temperature in the car
- The installation process requires a bit effort, but not as much as Dynamat
FatMat is pretty much the middle child among all the other sound deadeners we’ve already mentioned – It’s not the most expensive, neither is it the cheapest. It’s not the best in regards to overall quality, but it still gets the job done.
So before we give our final verdict concerning which of the four soundproofing materials actually makes for the best buy, let’s pause to take a look at what factors must be considered to pick the best sound deadening material for your needs.
How to Pick Best Soundproofing Material Between Noico, FatMat, Dynamat, and Killmat?
Sound Isolation Types
Weight and Flexibility of the Material
The composition of the sound deadening material will go a long way in determining its effectiveness and durability. For instance, butyl-based materials are lightweight and dense enough to be effectively soundproof. The material is also heat resistant and flexible.
On the other hand, asphalt-based materials are good at soundproofing but have the downside of not being heat resistant, are less flexible, and can have an undesirable odor. This shows that knowing the material type and its features will help you determine not only if the product will serve your desired purpose but will also satisfy all your other specifications.
Durability is key to being able to enjoy an installed sound deadener for as long as possible. The more durable the product is, the longer it will last and perform optimally after installation.
The thicker the material is, the better. This is because the thickness or the density of a sound deadening product determines its ability to block and absorb sound and vibrations. The denser a material is, the more effective it will be at soundproofing.
Purchasing soundproofing material is one thing while installing it is something else entirely. The faster and easier it is to install, the sooner you can begin enjoying its benefits. Look out for a material that is self-adhesive and whose installation process is uncomplicated. The fewer the steps in the installation process, the better.
This ties in with installation difficulty. If the material sheets are too large, installing them in a car can be difficult, especially since you have to cut the material first. And if the material sheet is too small, it can take a lot of time installing it piece by piece on a large surface.
To get a material that’s of the right size, first consider the surface it will be installed on and if there are uneven areas. This will help you determine if large or smaller sheets will make for a faster and more effective installation.
So which is better between Fatmat, Noico, Dynamat, and Kilmat?
The best way to decide if a product is right for you is to try it for yourself. But to help you bypass the costs of trial and error, we’ve tried the Fatmat, Noico, Dynamat, and Kilmat sound deadening mats for you and here’s what we think about which is better.
In the case of Dynamat vs FatMat vs Noico vs Kilmat, FatMat comes out as the least when it comes to overall performance. But let’s take a look at other points of comparison.
Price-wise, Dynamat is the most expensive, costing as much as $150 for a pack. Noico and Kilmat are the least expensive costing about $66 and $56 respectively. This makes Kilmat the most affordable among the four options.
This doesn’t mean that Dynamat is a bad option simply because it is the most expensive. After all, it is touted as one of the best sound deadeners on the market, and if you can afford it, you can buy it. But Kilmat and Noico due to their cost-effectiveness and individual quality can both serve as less expensive alternatives that still get the job done.
The cost-effectiveness of Kilmat and Noico also make them especially good options if you have a large soundproofing project in mind. But if you want the absolute cheapest option that still delivers great value, Kilmat is the way to go.
Regarding thickness/density, Noico, Fatmat, and Kilmat are all 80 mils thick, unlike Dynamat which is 50 to 60 mils thick. As you already know, when it comes to soundproofing the thicker the better.
Dynamat’s 50 mils thickness is above average when you look at other products in the market, but this doesn’t really give it an upper hand in this particular contest.
This makes Dynamat the loser in terms of thickness and Noico, Fatmat and Kilmat equal. Because of the higher 80 mils thickness of Noico, Fatmat, and Kilmat, all three can be expected to perform anywhere between 20% and 50% better as sound deadeners.
Effectiveness and Reliability
This is probably the most relevant comparison to consider. Regardless of if you spend a lot or a little on a sound deadener material, you want it to be something that actually works and that you can rely on for a long time to come without complications
In terms of effectiveness and reliability, FatMat is probably the least reliable. While it has a strong adhesive that ensures the sound deadening mat will be stuck to whatever surface you attach it for a very long time, the product’s asphalt-based material is its downfall.
Asphalt-based materials just aren’t as effective as butyl-based materials. Also, FatMat’s material tends to leave an odor and isn’t heat resistant, which can make it problematic during hot seasons.
This brings us to Noico and Kilmat which are both butyl-based products but it seems that Kilmat takes the upper hand because Noico has an asphalt underlay. This leads to certain issues such as Noico’s odor and reduced heat resistance.
Dynamat, on the other hand, is already regarded by the market to be fully reliable and effective at sound deadening. The product is very popular and has millions of users that attest to its quality and reliability. It is also butyl based.
So while Kilmat is great in its own right, Dynamat wins the effectiveness and reliability round due mostly to its longstanding and well-earned reputation as a top-quality sound deadening material
That said, Kilmat and Noico are both great at their job and will definitely make a cheaper and just as effective alternative for Dynamat. Especially Kilmat because it is odorless and doesn’t have an undercoating of asphalt like Noico.
Ease of Use and Installation
While price and effectiveness are definitely important, how easy the product is to install is also very important. After all, a difficult to install product will cost you more time and might even need an expert to get the job done. Hiring an expert for installation will add to the cost of installing the product.
Dynamat might be a more established brand that’s considered highly effective by many, but that doesn’t change the fact that the product can be quite tricky to install. Installation difficulty is especially high if installing Dynamat for the first time with no prior experience installing soundproofing.
This leads to many customers incurring the extra cost of having a professional install it on their behalf.
That said, if you watch a tutorial video or two on YouTube before you get started, you’ll find the installation process easier as you progress with the process.
As for FatMat, installation can be also tricky due to its extremely strong adhesive that is unforgiving of mistakes. Once the adhesive sticks to a surface, removing the material becomes almost impossible and can complicate installation.
Noico and Kilmat, on the other hand, are easier to install than the aforementioned two because they are lightweight and very flexible. Especially Killmat because of its smaller sheets which make for easy handling.
Even beginners with no experience can have an easy time installing either one of these two. They also require no additional kit to complete installation, making Noico and Kilmat both winners for ease of installation and use.
So who is the overall winner
To select a winner, it is important to avoid going for a product simply because it is the cheapest available option. Going for the most expensive with the mindset that it will be the best is also not your best move.
Because each product comes with its own list of unique shortcomings and features, opt for the option that offers more of the features you need and shortcomings that you are willing to live with.
That said, all the products discussed in this article will all serve well as quality sound deadeners that will minimize noise and vibrations. But if you are looking for a quality product and want to save money, then Kilmat makes for a great choice that offers the right balance of features.
But if what you want is a product that is more publicly recognized and has more satisfied customer reviews, and are willing to pay the price, then Dynamat might be just what you are looking for.