I bought a $20 pair of NICETOWN blackout curtains for the kids’ TV room. They made the room dark enough to watch TV during the day. What I wanted to know was whether closing them would also quiet the traffic I could hear through the window. Some listings called these curtains “soundproof,” and with over 100,000 Amazon reviews at the time, I understood why people kept asking me about them.
I had another option to compare them with. A few years earlier, Indow had sent me a clear acoustic insert made to fit my window. I put the generator test from that project alongside two curtain tests using recorded traffic and music. The insert made an audible difference. With the curtains, I had to listen hard to hear any change at all.
What an $800 insert adds to a double-pane window
My test window already had two panes of glass with an insulating space between them. The Indow insert sits on the room side, leaving another air gap between the panel and the existing glass. There’s a compressible gasket around the entire panel. When I pushed it into the frame, I could feel it seat tightly all the way around.

The fit is why Indow sent a measuring tool before making the panel. The insert comes back sized for that particular opening. I can press it into place and pull it back out when I want to open the window. That makes it an option for a rental where replacing the window is off the table. It also adds an insulating layer while letting me keep the daylight and the view.
In the video I put custom panels at roughly $300 to $800, with mine at about $800. I put many sound-deadening curtains in the $30 to $70 range. The pair I actually tested was cheaper again at around $20. Those were the prices I discussed at the time.
The generator test and what the 20 dB figure means
I used a generator outside because I could change its sound by adding a load. Running unloaded, it had a higher pitch. Under load, it got a little louder and the pitch dropped. I listened from inside and used my decibel meter to compare the different window and panel positions. The insert reduced the two generator sounds by a similar amount in this setup.
There’s an important detail if you’re using my result to decide whether to buy one. Near the end of the generator segment, I opened the existing window to hear what the insert could do on its own. That’s the part of the video where I reported a reduction of more than 20 dB. I wouldn’t budget for a 20 dB improvement on top of an already closed double-pane window based on that number.
I included the open-window comparison because people with older single-pane windows were asking about the panel. A single pane is a different starting point from my double glazing. If your bedroom faces a noisy street, check which type you have before comparing your window with mine. You can see more of the panel and how it fits in my original Indow review.
The $20 curtain test with traffic and music

My regular curtains actually cost more, but light passed through them. The NICETOWN pair was sold as a three-layer blackout curtain. I could feel a middle layer when I handled the fabric. Once I closed them, I couldn’t see light coming through the material, even up close.
For the sound test, I put a speaker outside and played a recording of road traffic. Real cars make a poor before-and-after test. One loud truck during the first reading can make almost anything look good on the second. I restarted the recording at the same seven-minute mark so I could hear the same stretch of traffic with the window uncovered and with the curtains drawn.
I could still hear the traffic clearly. The panels were narrower than my regular curtains, so I checked the gap where the two met in the middle. They hung close to the wall, reached the floor, and extended past the sides of the window. I covered the center separation as well. I heard very little change.
Next I switched to loud music. That gave the curtains something other than road rumble to work with. Again, I heard little difference. My estimate in the video was that there might have been about 1 dB between the two conditions. I’d describe that as barely detectable in this test. The generator and speaker were different sources, so these figures aren’t a head-to-head rating for the two products.
Would hanging the curtains in deeper folds help?
If you clap in a room with bare glass and hard walls, part of what you hear is sound reflecting back at you. Thick fabric can absorb some of those reflections. Leaving fullness in a curtain puts more fabric across the opening and can help the room sound less echoey. That’s a good reason to leave some folds when you hang curtains in a TV room.
The traffic test asks a different question. By the time those curtains absorb a reflection, the sound has already entered the room. Even with overlap at the sides and fabric down to the floor, the curtains don’t form the continuous seal I could feel when I installed the clear panel. Rearranging the folds wouldn’t persuade me to buy this pair for road noise.
What I’d buy for each room
For the kids’ TV room, I’d buy the $20 curtains again. The blackout worked, and being able to watch TV in daylight was worth the price alone. Amazon didn’t sponsor the test.
For a bedroom where outside noise is the reason I’m spending money, I’d put that money toward a properly fitted insert. It was the one of these two options that made the generator noticeably quieter inside, and I could leave it in during the day. If a custom panel is outside your budget, I’ve also compared 12 ways to quiet a noisy window, including options where you can give up the view.
Jump to a sound test
- 0:00 – Can You Really Soundproof a Window?
- 1:38 – Testing the Indow Window Insert
- 3:10 – Real Generator Sound Test
- 4:49 – How Much Noise Does the Insert Block?
- 6:09 – Testing $20 Soundproof Curtains
- 7:46 – Traffic Noise Test
- 8:07 – Soundproofing vs Sound Deadening
- 9:25 – Do the Curtains Actually Block Noise?
- 10:35 – Music Sound Test
- 11:20 – Are $20 Soundproof Curtains Worth It?
- 12:40 – Final Thoughts
Curtains and window materials
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Using these links supports Soundproof Guide at no extra cost to you.
